Why do we need male contraceptives?

A recent article published in Bloomberg Businessweek1 has painted a grim picture of family planning practices in India by coercing women into sterilization. In the village of Sonhoula, 33 women, many of them poor, were forced into sterilization because each woman received either $10 or a modest increase in welfare benefits from local officials. These women accepted the offer out of desperation without receiving counseling on alternative birth control methods (Fig. 1). What is more striking is that the $10 accepted by these women is equivalent to 1 wk wages for a poor family, sufficient to feed at least three children. In the clinic, a medical assistant pricked each woman's finger to test for anemia using the same needle. A surgeon then cut and tied each woman's fallopian tubes with a rusted scalpel on a makeshift operating table (elevated from the floor with bricks and covered with a blood-stained sheet) in a 3 min operation. The scalpel was then washed with warm water and re-used for another patient. Women were then laid shoulder-to-shoulder on the floor in a separate room for recovery, with nurses walking around and offering painkillers. When the anesthetic ran out, the surgeon substituted a weaker drug, but since these women were not completely unconscious during the procedure, this medical practice is dangerous.